Quote:
Originally Posted by Rachel Bronwyn
"Not your best" is just criticism. It's not constructive. If someone doesn't want to hear it in their private little corner of the internet, that's fine. Most people with DeviantArt accounts don't create them with the intent of pursuing constructive feedback. They create them to share. If they don't want unhelpful feedback in that setting, banning people who give it is reasonable.
|
He bans all criticism, constructive on not. **every comment is basically "WOW THIS IS SO GOOD!" and the only "negative" are minor like "That joint looks a little weird."
Again, no it is not. Banning someone who says something you don't like is childish, not the sign of maturity. It actually shows that you know your work isn't that good and don't want people to believe there are problems with it. Let them say it, if you believe it is wrong it doesn't matter and shouldn't bother you. An adult response is to ask for clarification, not take it as an insult and ban the person.
And btw, critique and criticism are basically same thing. It is just criticism is used to push away critiques you don't like. Critiques are not required to be constructive or not. You are playing semantics.
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/critique
Definition #2 a criticism!
Don't correct someone when you do so incorrectly.