BE Size preference.

[Archangel-Dreadnought]

I think this poll is a little off. Cup size depends on manufacturer and country, so it's not universal (making it kinda pointless). Also, you seem to be asking two different question, you assume that some one favorite size is also the largest they like.

Anyways, here's my thoughts on all the sizes you list:

"Big (F thru GG cup) grapefruit/small melon"
This one is more like small or just getting started. I must say, either you have some huge grapefruits in your local grocery store, or some small bras in the clothing department.

"Really Big (H to JJ cup) volleyball/basketball"
Good size for a more realistic BE. Thought, not sure the bra size matches, kinda the reverse of the first one. Also doesn't help that cup size is tied to band size and it's wacky.

"Huge (K to N+ cup) medicine ball/watermelon"
Isn't medicine ball the same size as a basketball? Anyways, the watermelon is a bit of a variable size comparison, I've seen some really small one (like smaller than a basketball) and some huge ones (about 5 time the volume of a basketball). So, for this one I'll use the largest I've seen, this is about the size that I'd use with FMG and BE, though maybe a little less.

"Massive (no bras) beach balls/bean bag chairs"
This kind a describes two different types of BE, one being inflation with air like a balloon and the other a bit more realistic. I have to say that I like the more pneumatic style at this size.
The beanbag chair works better for butt expansion, you always have a chair with you.

"Enormous - even larger but she can still walk"
Probably the largest size that I like, but, not my absolute favorite. Kinda needs to be the boob-loon style for it to work.

"Wow - fills the room, blocks out the sun"
Room filling is fun to draw every now and then, but, its limited on how you can make it interesting. Anything bigger starts to get more in to an abstract meta of some kinda.


My final though is that you should have used a visual chart for the poll options (there are a few floating around that might have worked). And as far as my favorite size, really don't have one, just whatever works.

[spacehillbilly]

Originally Posted by JJStrebas

I agree. In my writing I try to avoid painting myself into a corner by having my characters grow too big too fast because, to me, it gets harder to describe or less exciting to describe. And if they stop growing, the story grinds to a halt.

So far the results of the poll reinforce what I feel is my comfort zone since the votes tend to settle into really big/huge for the most part. I try to dabble and accomodate those with other tastes which is why the very first story I punlished deals in massive and enormous plus, but the majority of my stories do not and stop at huge.

You pretty much have the same taste as I do.

[JJStrebas]

Wow okay, like I said this was not a scientific poll. I just wanted to take the temperature of the community to help with my writing and this has done it. Thanks for your input.

[BE69]

I don't think the size is the only matter in the BE process, for a graphic support the tits must conserve a realistic shape, not just be cartoonish inflating balloons attached to the torso of the woman, the areolae and the nipples must grow with the tits (it's not mandatory that it is proportionnal).
And for a non-graphic written story, it must not use bra size but comparison mostly to body parts lessly to objects (for instance I find "as big as her head" easier to visualize than just a letter). Moreover with the bra size, most of the writers use the american bra size and, while I grasp the general idea, I don't get it cause I'm french (why the double letter system, people?). And some writers don't have a clue of how works the bra size system (B isn't a bad size, it correctly fills the palm of the hand).

[vincent_richter]

More to the point "her DD's quickly swelled to GGG's" is one of the least sexy things I've ever read, and I've already stated my preference errs towards larger. It's this disease of losing the key expository tactic of "show, don't tell" - "within seconds, her comfortable handfuls grew to unholy melons that staggered the imagination".

[Blake Isaac Gordon]

Originally Posted by vincent_richter

More to the point "her DD's quickly swelled to GGG's" is one of the least sexy things I've ever read, and I've already stated my preference errs towards larger. It's this disease of losing the key expository tactic of "show, don't tell" - "within seconds, her comfortable handfuls grew to unholy melons that staggered the imagination".

Gonna have to second this big time.

Also is the growth/size change reversible?
If yes then size means nothing. If no then only a solid handful of cup increases to keep things humane.

[OhZone]

It depends on the story. I think larger than a bean bag chair is too much, unless GTS goes with it. I like fairly slow BE usually, having her clothes strained - having to get new items. Alternately loving it and being worried. Finally getting dragged down and unable to move while her friends try to help her maybe. Maybe milking her? Maybe it's contageous. OHMY! And extra sensitivity is always nice. I think of nipples as orgasm enhancers! ha So bigger ones = bigger orgasms? But maybe that's just me!

[Prof_Sai]

There is a point where they just aren't boobs anymore and become some foreign attachment.

[spacehillbilly]

I prefer to stop at huge.

[JJStrebas]

To help with visualization for the first 3 categories...
Big = Tessa Fowler, Ewa Sonnet, Denise Milani
Really Big = Wendy Fiore, Hitomi, Sarah Rae, Charlie Cooper - the last two straddle the line between Really Big and Huge depending on their weight.
Huge = Alaura Grey, Karla James, Kristina Milan (all after weight gain), Leanne Crowe, Lantti Irres, Roxi Red on up to Chelsea Charms and Himiwako

[BillPratt]

I do because I use it to describe suggested sizes to the artist. I don't know if it is cleared for public display. Mostly I use it because it reduces the likelihood of

Black haired sex toy. Slender and finely toned, she has the sort of body used to sell exercise gear and nutritional supplements. And boob jobs. Full, G-cup breasts swell out like teardrops from her chest and are capped by thimble-like erect nipples. Acne what’s that? Her face and body are blemish free. Her sharp face has filled out into heart shape with perpetually kissy, bow-shaped lips and twinkling blue eyes. She stands tall to emphasize her bust, moves like a stripper on the make, and wears her hair bob-cut and swept emo style over her face the same as before, but now it adds an air of mystery to offset how on display the rest of her body is.

showing up in the comic as



and mucking up the dialog where Niki refers to her cupsize as being around a G cup.

[Blake Isaac Gordon]

Originally Posted by BillPratt

I do because I use it (Expansions Fan Ranking) to describe suggested sizes to the artist. I don't know if it is cleared for public display...

You know my biggest frustration with the www.expansionfan.com/comics/ is all their 'searchable' TAGS.

I've looked around the site to see if there is any type of specific explanation for what each tag means and... I've found nothing. (Guess you got to use a thesaurus...)

I still and will always appreciate the TOB simple but elegant size gradient system:
*Large but realistic size*
*Unrealistically huge*
*Room-filling or larger*