Woman into Tree

[TF-Viewer]

Originally Posted by Sandstar

I would consider it a death scene, even if she transformed into a tree, since I think that they're no longer that person

In this scene her fucking head exploded, her brains went all over. She actually died, nothing uncertain or existential about that. If that's a transformation,
so is falling into a wood chipper.

Don't overthink it. That lady straight up died.

[Sandstar]

Originally Posted by TF-Viewer

In this scene her fucking head exploded, her brains went all over. She actually died, nothing uncertain or existential about that. If that's a transformation,
so is falling into a wood chipper.

Don't overthink it. That lady straight up died.

Why are you arguing with me when I agree with you?

[TF-Viewer]

Originally Posted by Sandstar

Why are you arguing with me when I agree with you?

We don't though. You consider it a death because she transformed into a tree and she died in some existential way due to her personality ceasing to be.

But it's actually a death because a tree grew out of her and caused her to explode. It's not a transformation at all.

It's the difference between saying someone was transformed into ashes vs someone being burned to death until there was only ashes left after their gruesome demise.

[Sandstar]

Originally Posted by TF-Viewer

We don't though. You consider it a death because she transformed into a tree and she died in some existential way due to her personality ceasing to be.

But it's actually a death because a tree grew out of her and caused her to explode. It's not a transformation at all.

It's the difference between saying someone was transformed into ashes vs someone being burned to death until there was only ashes left after their gruesome demise.

No. I said it would be a death scene, to me, even if she did turn into a tree. Indicating that I thought that I didn't think she turned into a tree, and thus agreed with you. I was just making a seperate point about how it didn't matter to me whether she turned into a tree, or one grew out of her, she'd be dead either way.

[TF-Viewer]

Originally Posted by Sandstar

No. I said it would be a death scene, to me, even if she did turn into a tree. Indicating that I thought that I didn't think she turned into a tree, and thus agreed with you. I was just making a seperate point about how it didn't matter to me whether she turned into a tree, or one grew out of her, she'd be dead either way.

The follow up I also don't agree with. A person turning into something doesn't mean they died. Identity death and actual death aren't the same thing. One is literal, the other is existential.

Look, if I tell you we don't agree on something, don't argue with me and try to convince me that we do.